From the cocoon Samsung has come out no butterfly, but a horrible moth

From the cocoon Samsung has come out no butterfly, but a horrible moth

Samsung has recently unveiled on the stage of its Unpacked event the new Galaxy S10, S10+, S10 5G and S10e. The new flagship family will also be accompanied by the first flexible smartphone of the Korean company called Galaxy Fold. Samsung has used as a promotional image for the smartphone a beautiful butterfly although in my opinion from the cocoon of the company came out a hideous moth.

Don't get me wrong: moths are interesting animals, just like this Galaxy Fold is interesting. The first Samsung device to use the Infinity Flex foldable display has all the features to be a good first attempt in this new category of smartphones, however there is a not inconsiderable detail that made me jolt...

What is the purpose of a folding display?

I have no idea. And I don't think the companies that are presenting these devices have one either. I'll be honest with you, apart from having the ability to use a larger screen and turn your smartphone into a tablet, at the moment I don't see much use.

However, the technology is young and the best use cases will be explored over time. I trust in this way to see these products. We need a "first" folding device if we want to see the category improve and spread.

Ok having three apps open at the same time is pretty cool I have to admit... / © NextPit

One thing is for sure: no one wants a tablet with a notch on it

One of the reasons you can think of adopting this solution that uses a smartphone display on the outside and a folding display on the inside of the device, is to give users more surface area on which to enjoy their multimedia content. However, the statement "having more usable space for content" does not justify the existence of a notch.

Samsung hasn't gone crazy and hasn't put a notch in the main display of the smartphone. They haven't done so far, so why would they do it now? Instead, it's much worse. Take a look at this picture:

(ツ)_/¯ / © NextPit

The company has decided well to ruin (yes, I'm harsh but Samsung deserves it) a product that could revolutionize (or at least tantalize) the industry with... well, that stonking huge notch you see in the picture above. There are 3 possible "faces" of the smartphone where you could put these cameras: why on earth ruin the display from the larger diagonal, what people are supposed to use to read books, watch videos and, why not, even to play with that monstrosity?

As some of you may know I'm not an avid notch detractor, I love my Pixel 3 XL despite the monstrous notch. However, I find the solutions of Royole and the forerunners of folding smartphones much more suitable for everyday use. Who wants to use a tablet for selfies? Nobody, that's why ZTE's Axon M has cameras on the outside.

I find that Samsung has missed a great opportunity, to present the first folding smartphone that can become mainstream at least in the segment of buyers who want a premium smartphone and are willing to pay dearly.

What do you think of this Samsung Galaxy Fold? Masterpiece or monster?


Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing
Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing

  • BruinGuy Feb 21, 2019 Link to comment

    Authors that use phrases like "no one wants" trying to imply that they speak for everyone immediately lose their credibility.

  • Albin Foro Feb 21, 2019 Link to comment

    I feel somewhat vindicated. In 2012 I got my first 3.5" LG smartphone, found it delightful and that I was unexpectedly reading ebooks and browsing. In 2014 for a bigger screen, bought an 8" Acer tablet for around the house, and kept the little phone. Ever since, my personal use case has been "carry about" small phone and "around the house" wifi tablet, with same familiar launchers, overlapping apps and cloud sync of offline storage. That two-device personal use case never requires an "always with me" tablet, but I'm not everybody. (I'll assume Samsung early adopter pricing will get reasonable sooner than later.)

  • Justin Cohen Feb 21, 2019 Link to comment

    I agree. The inside notch is a deal breaker for me. But, any notch or hole in a screen is a deal breaker for me. Bezels are fine. The Note 9 does it right.

  • James F Scheiner Feb 21, 2019 Link to comment

    I give Samsung a lot of credit for producing this product. I'd love to use one for a few weeks before passing judgement.

  • Rusty H. Feb 21, 2019 Link to comment

    The price is WAY out of line. I wouldn't pay over 500 for ANY smartphone, folding screen or not.

  • storm Feb 21, 2019 Link to comment

    not my taste in design certainly. but that's been true since the curved edge screens.

Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing