Readers' Choice Awards results are in! The best and worst phones of 2015

Readers' Choice Awards results are in! The best and worst phones of 2015

We recently surveyed our loyal readership to vote in our annual AndroidPIT Reader's Choice Awards. We didn't want to bog you down with a long survey, so we posed just two very simple, but critical, questions: what were the best and worst Android phones of the year? The results were interesting, and both winners could have easily switched places with their runner-up.

Readers' choice: best phone of 2015

When it came to hyperbole and hype-beasting this year, there were only really three contenders: the OnePlus 2, Galaxy S6 Edge and Nexus 6P. Not surprisingly, two of these phones took the top spots for reader's choice of phone of the year.

The over-hyped OnePlus 2 was not one of them. Despite being a solid phone, the OnePlus 2 was actually the third-least voted-for device on the short list. So what took the number one spot?

AndroidPIT Readers Choice Awards Best Phone 2015
The Nexus 6P wins with a quarter of the vote. The S6/S6 Edge comes in second with one-fifth. / © ANDROIDPIT

The Nexus 6P. If it weren't a Nexus I'd almost be tempted to call it an underdog, considering the relative lack of attention the 6P in the run up to its release, when it lived largely in the shadow of the highly anticipated Nexus 5X

But once the curtains were pulled back, the spotlight only shone on the Nexus 6P. We loved it. You loved it. 'Nuff said.

androidpit Nexus 6P
The Nexus 6P is your pick for the best Android smartphone of 2015. / © ANDROIDPIT

Readers' choice: worst phone of 2015

A couple of phones stood out for their lack of polish this year. The Xperia Z3+ was almost comical in its poor performance, app crashing and overheating. Sony's response – that it would prefer to have a great camera that crashes after 20 seconds than to have a decent camera that works all the time – was equally troubling. But the Z3+ didn't strike our readership as the worst phone of 2015.

AndroidPIT Readers Choice Awards Worst Phone 2015
It was a close race between the Xperia Z3+ and the HTC One M9. / © ANDROIDPIT

No, that 'honor' went to none other than the phone that really kicked off the whole overheating Snapdragon 810 debate: the HTC One M9. Heavily criticized for looking almost identical to its predecessor, HTC's attitude of “if it ain't broke, don't fix it” clearly didn't resonate with fans of the HTC One line.

Add to that the heavily publicized failings of the processor inside the phone and the equally problematic fact that of all smartphone materials, metal feels hotter than plastic, and the HTC One M9 became the sacrifice to the overheating scandal the world demanded.

IMG 1044
You voted the HTC One M9 the worst Android phone of 2015. Whomp whomp... / © ANDRODIPIT

Looking forward

We never like to bag a phone out, and we have to admit the HTC One M9 is still a very nicely designed phone. If only you'd never seen the HTC One M8. Likewise, if it hadn't been for the problems caused by Qualcomm's poorly developed Snapdragon 810, half the 'bad' phones of 2015 wouldn't be on the shortlist at all.

It's been a wild year with more ultra-impressive phones than ever before. Smartphone camera tech has seriously improved, battery life has become vastly better thanks to Marshmallow, and design is suddenly something that all companies are taking seriously.

We want to thank you for your votes and look forward to hearing more of your opinions in 2016: we can't wait to see what happens.

  • If you haven't checked out the comments in the original survey, do so now. There are a few worthy mentions in there.

What phone are you most looking forward to in 2016? Make yourself heard in the comments.

Liked this article? Share now!
Join the discussion

Latest articles

Recommended articles


Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing
Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing

  • Ryan Damper Dec 28, 2015 Link to comment

    6p does nothing for me doesn't seem to excell at anything, brings nothing that hadn't been seen before apart from stock marshmallow. Bit of a farce that something so unoriginal can win.

  • Arpit Saini Dec 23, 2015 Link to comment

    It's ridiculous how you people keep 3-4 different polls to make different phones win. There should only be 1 phone of the year. as I last remember s6edge won the last 2 competitions. Anyway I don't really care about this; 6P is definitely a great phone :)

  • An Droid Dec 23, 2015 Link to comment

    The Nexus 6P was voted the best phone for 2015? Is that the one with the cracking camera glass and paper thin frame? Oh yes, no SD card slot and non-removable battery?

  • Michael Detwiler Dec 23, 2015 Link to comment

    Pretty sad when you see an outstanding device like the HTC One M9 listed as worst. The device is outstanding, my wife loves hers and hasn't found anything to dislike about it. The 'overheating issue' is made up by unscrupulous reviews.

  • Dwarfer66 Dec 23, 2015 Link to comment

    I am very happy with S6 Edge!

Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing