Hot topics

Is Apple shooting itself in the foot by following Android with iOS 14?

app clips
© Apple

Read in other languages:

The UX, or the iOS user experience has always been Apple's big selling point. So much so that its followers forgive it for the iPhone's hardware lag over their Android competitors, but with the unveiling of iOS 14 on Monday, June 22, it happens to walk very closely in Android's footsteps. Does this mean that Apple is at risk of losing its trump card?

It has almost exploded as a meme overnight when I noticed this comparison between iOS 14 and Android on the sidelines of Apple's WWDC 2020 yesterday. The widgets that recall Windows Tiles, Apple Translate that seemingly emulates Google Translate, the App Clips that are inspired by Instant Apps, or even the Apple Maps update that follows in the footsteps of Google Maps, it is unnerving.

I think everyone got the picture and we've all had our fill of mocking iOS 14 jokes across numerous social networks. However, beyond the "Android is already doing it", these similarities between the two mobile operating systems do not deliver anything negative for users. In fact, you can even consider it to be a good thing, where there is a little more openness between the two systems or two dogmatic ways of thinking/getting things done.

But if we put ourselves in Apple's shoes, the similarities of iOS with Android, when it comes to features, is not necessarily the best idea. Obviously, it's normal and encouraging to see iOS deliver new features, especially if they have already proven themselves on their Android equivalents.

On the other hand, how can we justify the price of the iPhone, Apple's commercial strategy, and the exclusivity of its user experience if it will eventually end up with an identical user experience that is found on Android?

Apple "copies" Android: the obligation to do better

Even if Apple 'copies' or is inspired by Android, so what? I have not been on the iPhone for several years now. However, I know I could only look at the improvements announced for iOS 14 during WWDC 2020 yesterday with a positive view. It doesn't matter who's the first to launch a particular feature, what matters is this - what I'm using right now.

I don't care that Huawei was one of the first to offer a triple photo sensor on the P20 Pro. Copying ideas from one manufacturer to another, whether it be software or hardware, is a natural phenomenon in the wheel of technical progress.

It's also one of the excesses of marketing that sometimes leads to the proliferation of gimmicky features that tend to be presented as innovations simply because it's fashionable, even though it isn't. On the other hand, for Apple to be inspired by Android is one thing. It is important that the resemblance ought not be too striking or at least the emulation of it should not be too basic.

It's not a simple case of copying-and-pasting Android features. Hence, Apple has an obligation to do better as it is late to the game. Coming in second place with panache would be a more accurate description. Even though with that kind of buzz, it is still quite impossible to gauge its performance, as the iOS 14 beta has just been released and I have not been able to test it yet.

But what is certain is that Apple has fully mastered the strategy of making something new out of an old thing by perfecting it, where along the way it sometimes makes it better. So much so that every new thing, be it hardware or software, is touted to be a killer-feature.

Over and over again, why pay the full price for something old?

But let's take into account what was presented during the keynote into consideration. Unlike Android widgets which can be of any size and shape, iOS 14 widgets happen to be more uniform and come in three different sizes that can be modified in order to accommodate the amount of information that you would like to see.

With the Smart Stack feature, you can create a pile or stack of widgets that can be moved around and take up the same amount of space as that of a single widget. This way, you don't have to browse multiple pages containing multiple widgets.

iOS 14 also uses AI to toggle widgets in the same stack based on time, location, and user activity. For example, it can display a news widget early in the morning and a summary of your activity at the end of the day. This is intuitiveness on a whole new level that cannot be found on Android.

Screenshot 2020 06 22 at 19.11.18
Widgets under iOS 14 and their resemblance to Android or Windows Tiles. / © Apple, Screenshot: AndroidPIT

Another example: the App Library which is based on the Android app drawer. This time around, Apple decided to take a different approach here compared to Android. The App Library in iOS 14 automatically groups different types of applications into clearly identified folders.

You don't even have to do this yourself to organize your application pages, and the best part is, you can hide as many application pages as you want. By swiping to the right, the App Gallery shows you the recently added applications in a box at the top. In short, it's much less chaotic than the application pages in Android, at least on paper anyway.

Screenshot 2020 06 22 at 19.29.20
The App Library under iOS 14 the equivalent of application pages in Android. / © Apple, Screenshot: AndroidPIT

We return to the obligation of the company to do better in order to stand out. Apple has been doing this for several years now with varying degrees of success. Optimization rather than innovation happens to be a choice that can be criticized, but it is the one adopted by Cupertino.

The problem, in my opinion, is that even if Apple stands out by doing better while copying Android, the firm is likely to attract a fewer number of new users. Existing iPhone and iOS fans are already in place, and they are the ones who would be happy with the new improvements.

But what about Android users, who would like to take the plunge? If the iOS user experience is what makes the iPhone so appealing, and justifies their generally higher price for lower specification hardware, will these potential defectors still be as motivated to switch to the Apple's side?

Why pay more for a smartphone if the features offered already exist on Android, especially on cheaper Android-powered models? No doubt about it, I speculate and extrapolate such thoughts. We are not quite there yet, and thankfully Apple has many other things going for it such as the unparalleled strength of its product ecosystem.

But I think that in the long run, the Apple brand will have to work hard to find a new demarcation criterion, an "Apple" touch that makes its products and services unique. What they need is a revolution and not evolution. After all, it's about time.

Other interesting reads on AndroidPit:

The best smartphones under $1,000 

  Editor's recommendation The best iPhone The best camera phone Value for money The best foldable The most affordable
  • $799
  • $799
  • $999
  • $599
  • $999
  • $499
Picture Samsung Galaxy S24 Product Image Apple iPhone 15 Product Image Google Pixel 8 Pro Product Image Nothing Phone (2) Product Image Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 5 Product Image Google Pixel 7a Product Image
Review: Samsung Galaxy S24
Review: Apple iPhone 15
Review: Google Pixel 8 Pro
Review: Nothing Phone (2)
Review: Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 5
Review: Google Pixel 7a
Go to comment (5)
Antoine Engels

Antoine Engels
Senior Editor

Black belt in specs sheet analysis. OnePlus fanboy in (slow) remission. Average estimated reading time of my articles: 48 minutes. Tech deals fact-checker in my spare time. Hates talking about himself in the 3rd person. Dreams he was a gaming journalist in another life. Doesn't get the concept of irony. Head of editorial for NextPit France.

View all articles
Liked this article? Share now!
Recommended articles
Latest articles
Push notification Next article
Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing
Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing

  • Dean L. 34
    Dean L. Jun 27, 2020 Link to comment

    As I returned to iOS a few months back the one thing that I missed was PiP, well that's now coming to iOS. The success of iOS lies in the services and the seamless functionality. Are Android and iOS radically different? No. But Apple only has their own devices to support, where Android has many devices from numerous OEMs to support. And the years of iOS updates contributes to that success for those who don't upgrade their devices every year or two. Just my two pfennig...


    • 49
      storm Jun 28, 2020 Link to comment

      I need to rewrite this with my cynical ant-apple slant. Your points are valid, I just can't resist.

      The success of apple lies in the tech illiteracy of its consumers that don't know what they're giving away nor the more powerful techniques available. Apple pretends that lack of choice is strength and their way is the only proper way to do anything. Apple updates will intentionally cripple your functioning device to mislead you into premature unnecessary upgrades.

      Dwarfer66Dean L.

      • Dean L. 34
        Dean L. Jun 30, 2020 Link to comment

        Let's agree to disagree. LoL I would like to share my experience with my iPhone 5s which received 5 years of updates and received a few security updates after it's end of life. I might've still used it if the battery maintained a charge greater than 4 hours. I don't know any Android phone getting that type of update support. I'm not a gamer nor do I feel I have to upgrade every year or two. Another point is that there are fewer app phishing scams with iOS. Even some Android reviwers have stated that some apps are better on iOS than they are on Android. So as I said before, let's agree to disagree with knowing that we each have our own personal preferences. I value your comments & opinions as conversation & knowledge. Peace. Just my two pfennig...

  • 1
    satyam561 Jun 27, 2020 Link to comment

    it will be better than android in terms of animation ,resource usage such as battery ,ram ,computing power all that important things ,whereas android despite having first mover advantage like always will now wake up to reality ,insider leak pixel exclusive updated widget app drawer , widget optimised os comes next year will be coming to other at later date, you can always say tesla didn't invented electric cars but we all know it's perfecting it.

  • 49
    storm Jun 26, 2020 Link to comment

    Most of these are overly complex for little function. Same problem as the much vaunted and now dead 3d touch which became ? Long press. Whee.

Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing