Camera Test: HTC One vs. Xperia Z vs. Galaxy S3

Camera Test: HTC One vs. Xperia Z vs. Galaxy S3

When buying a smartphone, you're paying for all the bells and whistles and what you hope for, is that all these extra features really do what they say they will. Take cameras for example. This is a significant point that dictates whether a smartphone gets bought or stays on the shelves. Your smartphone is not only your telephone, but your camera, which you use to capture everyday memorable moments quickly and without any hassle. HTC has developed its new flagship, the HTC One, with ultra-pixel technology and our own Johannes Wallat at AndroidPIT, wanted to know if it really delivers.

NextPit Logo white on transparent Background
kamera vergleich teaser
© NextPit

The Taiwanese company, in attempts in creating a very impressive image quality, put less of an emphasis on augmenting the megapixel count. Instead, they focused on creating bigger pixels in order to capture more light and have less image noise. He compared it to the Sony Xperia Z and the Samsung Galaxy S3 and cranked all of these device's camera settings to a high ISO count of 800. Then he took several pictures in bad lighting conditions, as well of objects with bright colors. The image noise was also pre-set. Before we started the test, he thought that HTC One would be the best camera.

Cameras put to test in difficult conditions 

The test is hardly a complete test, but one we thought would nonetheless interest our readers. He took three different pictures, one in diffused lighting, one with a fruit bowl still life and finally, one of a coffee cup in front of a blue bottle. Something worth mentioning is that the ISO, which is used to set light sensitivity, was set quite high (800) for a smartphone. During the testing, all of the cameras were up to par. However, the HTC One didn't come out a winner, like we had previously speculated.

htc one galaxy s3 xperia z kamera vergleich 1

Picture 1: Here Johannes turned on a lamp, in order to lighten the room a little. HTC One's colors are really pale, while the Xperia Z clearly has more image noise. The Galaxy S3 comes out a winner in this first image round. / © NextPit

htc one galaxy s3 xperia z kamera vergleich 2

Picture 2: The same setting was used, except this time it was zoomed in. Galaxy S3 is again the winner in this round, though the blue background is a little blurry. The Xperia Z's picture is really saturated, while HTC One's colors appear matte and flat. However, the latter had very little image noise. / © NextPit

htc one galaxy s3 xperia z kamera vergleich 3

Picture 3: This was one was taken in complete natural lighting. The colors in the HTC One picture yet again lack vibrancy. S3's light sensor is not as developed as the other two, therefore the picture appears quite dark. The Xperia Z did its best work here, though the color brightness is at the expense of a clear image since the image noise is quite visible./ © NextPit

htc one galaxy s3 xperia z kamera vergleich 4

Picture 4: This time it was taken in natural light and at the same time, was zoomed in. This is where each smartphone didn't bring much to the table. HTC One did the best work here, though the colors lack vibrancy and have a touch of gray. / © NextPit

htc one galaxy s3 xperia z kamera vergleich 5

Picture 5: A dreary Berlin day and an inner courtyard: The HTC One produces the most detailed images and the S3 had the sharpest details, with the most contrast. Xperia Z's camera has the most image noise and produced the image with the worst quality. / © NextPit

Bottom Line

At the end of the day, the tests revealed that HTC One's camera isn't as impeccable as we had imagined, the others were easily comparable. HTC worked created natural, yet pale color rendering and produced relatively minor image noise. The Galaxy S3 created stronger contrasts and soft colors, while the Sony Xperia Z's pictures came out soft, with quite natural looking colors. But it could be said, that the latter created the worst pictures with the clearest image noise when taken in the the most difficult exposure situations.Johannes finds it interesting and surprising that the oldest of the three, the Galaxy S3, produces on average the best pictures. The other 2012 cameras are quite comparable to the HTC One's supposed ultra-pixel technology, however there is no clear winner.

To see all the pictures, click here.

What did you think of this test? Would you have done something differently? Which one was the best in your opinion?

Liked this article? Share now!
Join the discussion

Latest articles

Recommended articles

1 Comment

Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing
Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing

  • Gio A. Mar 19, 2013 Link to comment

    the verge also thit a similar test and that also showed that the htc one's canera really wasn't so ultra as htc wants you to believe. I find it sad that sony who has some of the best cameras on the market currently can't make a good phone camera. I wonder if they would be able to fix it with a future update. I would really hope so because I really find they have a very good phone. it's nice to see that last years model the S3 can still compeet with the newest models. that just goes to show that it's a quality product.

    Nice camera review, keep up the good work.