(Opinion) Physical keys vs Soft keys

  • Replies:7
  • OpenNot stickiedUnanswered
  9
AJ STA ANA
  • Forum posts: 55

Jan 2, 2014, 5:46:45 AM via Website

Which do you prefer for Android?

(Ex:Soft keys of Lg G2 vs Physical keys of Galaxy S4)

Reply
  7
Nik Burin
  • Forum posts: 54

Jan 2, 2014, 7:50:24 AM via App

physical,it just seems right and removes that ugly black stripe from the bottom of the screen

Reply
  23
sinkster
  • Forum posts: 610

Jan 2, 2014, 10:02:23 AM via Website

I've had phones with both and probably now prefer softkeys. Physical keys give you proper tactile feedback and don't take up screen estate, but can show signs of wear eventually and detract from clean lines. If you're new to softkeys it can take a while to familiarise yourself with them, but with KitKats immersive mode they no longer affect the display.

Sinkster

Reply
  35
Kris Carlon
  • Forum posts: 1,110

Jan 4, 2014, 12:00:42 AM via App

Soft keys for sure. KitKat's transparent system bars remove the black bars anyway (and the black bar for soft keys is usually occupied by actual phone (ie not screen) to house the physical keys on other devices). Plus, with soft keys you can customize them how you want, like on the G2 or with a custom ROM or alternate launcher. I'm using an S4 right now that has a sticky home key - no problems there with soft keys.

Follow Kris on Google+ and Twitter / Forum Rules - Recommended for new AndroidPIT members! / Important to all community members: please read before posting

Reply
  4
Vince
  • Forum posts: 25

Jan 4, 2014, 5:26:40 PM via Website

soft keys +1

Reply
  2
Nick H
  • Forum posts: 5

Jan 6, 2014, 1:25:02 AM via App

I'm using a Galaxy S4. The physical keys don't bother me to much, however I will say from playing around on my friend's Nexus, I'd much rather have soft keys. They just feel a whole lot nicer plus I think they look better too.

Reply
  4
Andrea
  • Forum posts: 25

Jan 10, 2014, 11:16:16 PM via Website

Soft all the way. They can disappear in games or video playback, they allow for swipe-up-for-GoogleNow, they're prettier when the device's off and rotate when's one and if in future Google decide to add or change the buttons set you don't need a new phone, just an update.

And I think they're much more responsive and easy-to-tap than a physical button such as Samsungs' central one.

Reply
  2
Haeydr
  • Forum posts: 11

Jun 19, 2014, 11:32:24 AM via Website

Soft keys, i thought i'd love going back to hard keys, but about 2 years ago when i used Samsung Galaxy Glide i started hating the slide out keyboard. It's very inconvenient now to always pull out the keyboard when we've been used to the onscreen keyboards now.

Reply